Is Google Killing the Concept of “Brand” in Their Updates?

The SEO and website industries are abuzz this week due to a so-called “leak” of google information. Others have referred to it simply as API data and not a true “leak”. Either way, the community is abuzz on several key fronts, particularly that we finally have information on how the ever-elusive Google works internally. Even if this is just a brief insight into the workings of the search engine, it did confirm for many that Google’s March core update was not only penalizing good sites, but was also a colossal slap in the face to smaller, more niche-blogs. There’s also growing concern since Google has been using websites to train Bard/Gemini without consent, but that’s an ever growing battle. I have a couple thoughts on this as somebody who has been in the web design industry for 10 years, then left to become a therapist. I also run a non-profit, and I still manage around 20 websites. Some of them for these businesses, others just for fun.
The website I saw the most hits on, funny enough, were the ones making the most ad revenue. Part of me wonders if Google is simply cracking the whip on its engine to try and save money—why wouldn’t it? Anyways, that’s neither here nor there. I don’t care about that site very much as I never expected it to make revenue in the first place. Besides, we’re not talking thousands, just a few $100. I did find it interesting.
What I’ve noticed, however, from my shift from running “branded” content to “personal content” (much of being a therapist is promoting YOURSELF) is that the current web is actually not brand friendly. Reddit answers and Quora answers are ranking not just because they are top level domains (but it helps) but because people are more likely to view social content.
And then… I thought about it some more. I can’t remember the last time I’ve felt “drawn” to a brand on youtube or facebook like I used to. I simply don’t care that much. And yet, we constantly consume tik toks, youtubers, and ‘influencers’. Rather than being ‘brands’ there’s a large shift to self content. In response to this, I changed my YouTube and Tik Tok to no longer feature my organization name but my own. It’s a weird feeling as the web seems to be becoming less friendly to a corporate landscape and more for a socialized one. For example, the google information that came out confirms that who your author is matters, and that google can actually link it to social profiles and other content. Google My Business now offers the option to add social profiles.
I think it’s ironic that Google is making the web more ‘social’ by removing the human touch and moving to a distilled AI-based model.
“Search Engine Optimization” now feels a bit more like “Personal Press Releases”. This is a new world for many, but I think there is some indication that at least right now, the web is moving away from websites and more to a person-driven approach. That is, so long as the ads from that content make revenue for google—and considering how much influencers are paid, we can assume that’s not going anywhere any time soon.
Google no longer seems to care what SEO you’re doing, they only care if users are engaging in content, satisfied, and kept in the ecosystem. Their AI scraping our content and stealing it isn’t helping matters either… where this goes is anybody’s guess, but for now, take my thoughts with a grain of salt—and then add lime and a margarita. All I’ll say is that I’m not jealous of those still in the industry.
11pm update I posted on the /r/SEO subreddit:
Wrote an article about google/brands, got banned from a subreddit permanently for sharing… then I realized that this is just part of the same problem. Reddit/Quora/social ranks higher now, but these are all run by mods who basically ban any links/posts they disagree with.
So, I left the field to become a counsellor. However, I still run a non-profit and my own businesses/etc, because why would I pay for that when I’ve done it for 10 years. Anyways… after trying to post a blog post and getting immediately banned with no warnings, it has me thinking… this is just part of the problem. Now, being banned from a subreddit isn’t something I’m going to go cry about, but if GOOGLE is going to prefer reddit ranks, but reddit itself is run by random moderators of communities who decide who lives and dies… then what? Social sites are more polarized than ever… and many times facebook groups, reddit pages, and other “top social sources” just remove content/ban without warning. We’re seeing a world where websites are being killed off for “social” content, but the social content is being wielded by the individuals who got there first and happened to aggregate. So, now what? Do we just… never grow anything? Never share ideas? Or, is the end goal that absolutely everything must be a post on that said social media site, garning more revenue in ads for both google and reddit/facebook/etc? So, own nothing yourself, have your content stolen by AIs, and only post on third party websites and never ever ever ever dare “SELF PROMOTE” (the gravest sin on reddit). Basically, the internet is becoming a homogenized shit show, and only the biggest win.
I hate it here.